It must be tough to make a movie about unemployment after “Up in the Air.” After Jason Reitman’s film so ingeniously brought employees who had actually been downsized in front of the camera to tell their stories, it felt to me like there was no other way to ever achieve the same candid honesty. I can imagine writer/director John Wells, who had to premiere his film “The Company Men” at Sundance only a month after Reitman’s hit theaters, probably muttered a few expletives under his breath when he realized he had to compete with it.
Yes, it does portray in pretty clear detail the effects of the 2008 financial collapse on the hard-working employee, but did it really pick the right protagonist? Granted I really don’t care for Ben Affleck unless he’s behind the camera, yet his Bobby Walker is suffering a crisis of luxury, not one of necessity. Is that the story of the recession? Tears shed over selling the Porsche and spousal fights over the country club membership. You would think that having to move back in with his parents temporarily was equivalent to moving below the poverty line.
When it’s not indulging us with the sob stories of siblings sharing beds (when the children who were really affected by the recession were sleeping on the floor), it’s giving us another indictment of post-too big to fail corporate America a la “Margin Call” and “Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps.” We get it, Hollywood, you think the corporate world is full of sleazes like Jim Salinger (Craig T. Nelson) who will actually say he works for the shareholders and not for the good of his employees. The man can’t even muster up any sympathy when one of his longest-tenured staffers commits the most clichéd act of desperation in film!
Depression is a sentiment a movie needs to earn to be justified, and “The Company Men” ultimately just wallows in self-pity rather than putting its stark depiction of a catastrophic time in American history to good use. When a protagonist seriously considers underemployment as a long-term alternative, then I start to question a film’s social compass. Yes, psychological satisfaction is important from your vocation … but does it balance with the intrinsic disappointment from not realizing your own sense of worth and potential? Such a decline in our guiding philosophy might be one of the sadder aspects of the recession.




The allure of “
In a year that saw nostalgia being wielded in various powerful ways, “




Recent Comments